It's my least favorite John Green book, but it still earns 3 stars. At times I found it amusing and entertaining while at other times it seemed absurd. I loved Tiny's character, but I got the impression that John Green was stereotyping gays and that didn't sit well with me. The story was much more about Tiny than either Will Grayson, so the title is misleading. I would have preferred a stronger ending because the way it ended had me thinking "That's it?" My favorite is by far The Fault in Our Stars.